Feedback is a necessary part of leadership, but it is also one of the fastest ways to erode trust when handled poorly. For Direct Support Professionals, feedback often feels personal because the work itself is personal. How supervisors deliver feedback can determine whether it leads to growth or disengagement.
Giving effective feedback is not about avoiding hard conversations. It is about having them in a way that preserves respect, strengthens relationships, and supports better outcomes.
Start with the Relationship, Not the Issue
Trust is built over time, not during a corrective conversation. When feedback only happens during problems, staff begin to associate leadership interaction with negativity. Regular check-ins, recognition, and presence create a foundation that makes feedback easier to receive when it is needed.
Feedback should never feel like a surprise.
Be Clear, Not Vague
Unclear feedback creates anxiety and confusion. Statements like “You need to be more professional” or “That didn’t go well” leave DSPs guessing what to change. Effective feedback is specific, factual, and focused on observable actions.
Clarity shows respect and helps staff understand expectations without feeling attacked.
Focus on the Work, Not the Person
Trust is damaged when feedback feels like a judgment of character rather than a discussion of practice. Address what happened, not who the person is. Separate intent from impact, and avoid assumptions about motivation.
When feedback stays focused on actions and outcomes, DSPs are more likely to stay open and engaged.
Explain the Why
DSPs are more receptive to feedback when they understand the reason behind it. Connecting feedback to safety, quality of support, individual preferences, or team consistency helps staff see the bigger picture.
Explaining the “why” reinforces that feedback is about improvement, not control.
Listen as Much as You Talk
Feedback should be a conversation, not a lecture. DSPs often have context leaders may not see—staffing challenges, environmental factors, or individual needs that influenced the situation. Listening does not mean excusing issues; it means understanding them.
When DSPs feel heard, trust is strengthened—even during difficult discussions.
Offer Support, Not Just Correction
Feedback without support feels punitive. Ask what the DSP needs to be successful. This might include additional training, clearer guidance, backup during challenging times, or follow-up conversations.
Supportive feedback communicates partnership rather than authority.
Follow Through
Nothing damages trust faster than inconsistent follow-through. If expectations change, reinforce them consistently. If support is offered, provide it. If improvement is acknowledged, say so.
Consistency shows that feedback is fair and meaningful, not arbitrary.
End with Confidence
Feedback conversations should leave DSPs feeling capable, not defeated. Reinforce confidence in their skills and their value to the team. When staff believe leadership still trusts them, they are more likely to grow from the feedback rather than withdraw.
The Bottom Line
Giving feedback without damaging trust requires intention, clarity, and empathy. When leaders approach feedback as a tool for support rather than correction, it strengthens relationships and improves performance.
Trust is not preserved by avoiding feedback—it is preserved by delivering it well.
Add comment
Comments